Detroit, MI — The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is shining a light on yet another dark side of American law enforcement. The practice of treating dispossessed citizens like human sanitation to be removed from destination areas so as to rid the general public of vivid reminders of our nation’s growing poverty problem.
A recent ACLU complaint filed with the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) alleges that Detroit Police Department (DPD) routinely takes homeless citizens off the streets in tourism/entertainment district in handcuffs. Transports them outside the city, stripping them of whatever small funds they might have on their person. And serves notice that they are to not relocate within city limits.
This practice of “dumping” has been rumored for years to occur in cities across the country. Other cities have found innovative ways to humanely address their homeless populations. Portland, for instance, has long grappled with a persistent flow of youth that results in 400 living on the street on any given day. Public-private partnerships have invested heavily in safe places to not only respond to general public concerns, but also to reduce incidents of violence against youth often committed by adults. Portland is not a fiscal panacea. However, Detroit is in a far less financially sound position. One of America’s most distressed major cities, Detroit is burdened with debt and turning to crisis measures, including following a course of Mayor Dave Bing’s territorial downsizing plan. Last December, City Councilwoman JoAnn Watson made national news after calling for President Obama to deliver the “bacon” to Detroit in-return for its overwhelming support of his second presidential run.
Fiscal challenges notwithstanding, DPD’s rounding-up of American citizens is reminiscent of the shameful internment of Japanese Americans after the attack on Pearl Harbor. Poor citizens, however smelly, un-groomed, and mentally-challenged as they might be, are American citizens nonetheless. John Donne’s bell tolls, and it tolls most loudly for these. Mahatma Gandhi said,“A nation’s greatness is measured by how it treats its weakest members.” Similar observations have been made by Pearl S. Buck, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Pope John Paul II, and others. If, indeed, DOJ confirms the ACLU’s allegations, what does this say about where we have arrived as a civilized nation?
Should, for the good of commercial or any other interests, police departments be allowed to indiscriminately kidnap private citizens?
Are we are a better society to be reminded of our failure to construct a decent existence for all our citizens or are we made better by hiding it?
What alternatives might budget-strapped cities pursue to address loitering, public safety, and safety of vulnerable homeless citizens?
Let me hear from you…
See below for the ACLU Press Release.
ACLU Urges Detroit To End Illegal Practice of ‘Dumping’ Homeless People Outside City Limits, Files DOJ Complaint
April 18, 2013FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CONTACT: (212) 549-2666; email@example.com
DETROIT – The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan sent a letter to the Detroit Police Department and filed a complaint with the United States Department of Justice (DOJ) today demanding an end to the Detroit police’s illegal and abusive tactics toward homeless individuals in the city. A yearlong ACLU investigation uncovered the disturbing practice of officers approaching individuals who appear to be homeless in the Greektown area, forcing them into police vans, and deserting them miles away.
“DPD’s practice of essentially kidnapping homeless people and abandoning them miles away from the neighborhoods they know – with no means for a safe return — is inhumane, callous and illegal,” said Sarah Mehta, ACLU of Michigan staff attorney. “The city’s desire to hide painful reminders of our economic struggles cannot justify discriminating against the poor, banishing them from their city, and endangering their lives. A person who has lost his home has not lost his right to be treated with dignity.”
Since January 2012, the ACLU has received numerous complaints from homeless individuals about the practice, which Detroit police officers have called “taking homeless people for a ride.”
Over the years, officers have frequently approached homeless individuals in Greektown – a section of Detroit that is popular with tourists because if its restaurants, bars and casino – and told them that they were not allowed to be there; forced them into police vans, sometimes in handcuffs; and drove them to remote areas of Detroit or neighboring cities before abandoning them.
In some cases, after taking homeless people “for a ride,” the officers ordered them to throw out any money in their pockets. As a result, the men had no option but to walk—often several miles and sometimes in the middle of the night through unlit and potentially dangerous neighborhoods—back to downtown Detroit where many of their shelters, warming centers, and churches are located.
To watch video of some of the men telling their stories, go to:http://www.aclumich.org/
The ACLU’s letter to Detroit documents the experiences of five individuals who were doing nothing illegal, yet were subjected to this abusive and unlawful treatment on multiple occasions.
- Andrew Sheehan, 37, was “taken for a ride” at least four times since December 2011. Andrew has been homeless on and off for several years because of a substance abuse problem. He has since completed a drug rehabilitation program and is now working, living in an apartment, and continuing to attend religious services at Saints Peter and Paul Church in Greektown. Andrew has been picked up several times while sitting on a manhole in Greektown to keep warm. Police have driven him anywhere from five to seven miles away. On one occasion officers said they were taking Sheehan to a shelter, but instead dropped him off at the boundary between Detroit and River Rouge on Fort Street—eight miles from where he was picked up.
- Dennis B., 54, has been homeless on and off for many years. In 2011, Dennis was “taken for a ride” by officers approximately four or five times. On several occasions, officers approached Dennis near St. Mary’s Church, frisked him for loose change, and insisted that he throw out any money in his pockets, removed him from Greektown and dropped him off around 6 Mile Road on the Detroit’s eastside. In January 2012, Dennis was again standing outside St. Mary’s Church when an officer told him he was not allowed to be in the area and subsequently took Dennis to the corner of Gratiot Street and Harper Street and left him there.
- Charles E., 58, has had a brain aneurism, experiences seizures, and has an ulcer in his leg. After his son’s death in 1992, Charles began to experience severe emotional and mental difficulties, leading to the loss of his job and home. On one evening in March 2012, Charles and his brother were walking on the sidewalk on Lafayette Street near Beaubien Street when police officers put them in the van and drove them to Buchanan Street in Southwest Detroit. Because Charles was afraid of what he might encounter in that area and despite the significant pain he was experiencing from the blood clots in his legs, he and his brother crossed the Lodge freeway and walked two hours back to downtown Detroit.
- Elvin D., 46, has been homeless, on and off, for four or five years. In the fall of 2012, Elvin was sleeping in Hart Plaza when, around midnight, a police officer approached him and offered to take him to a warming center. Instead of taking Elvin to a shelter, the officer dropped him off on Michigan Avenue in Dearborn. Elvin walked most of the night to return to downtown Detroit.
- Marvin S., 37, was standing on Woodward Avenue when two officers with the Wayne County Sheriff’s Department pulled up, handcuffed him, and placed him in the back of their squad car. Marvin demanded to know why he was being arrested, but the officers refused to answer his questions as they drove out of downtown Detroit. Eventually, the officers pulled over in Allen Park near the “World’s Largest Tire” near I-94, approximately 14 miles from downtown Detroit, and told Marvin to “get out.”
According to the ACLU’s letter and complaint to the DOJ, the Detroit Police Department’s tactics violate the constitutional rights of homeless people, including the right to due process and the right to be free of unreasonable search and seizures. Moreover, in arresting, detaining and forcibly removing homeless individuals without probable cause, Detroit Police officers are violating the 2003 consent judgment with the DOJ.
In its letter to the DPD, the ACLU writes: “Not only are police endangering the lives and violating the constitutional rights of homeless individuals, but in so doing, police are compromising the city of Detroit’s security by using their time and resources to harm rather than protect the city’s inhabitants.”
The ACLU asks the DOJ to investigate the practice as part of its mandate within the existing consent decree and to ensure that the rights of these vulnerable community members are protected. In addition, the ACLU asks the City of Detroit to end the practice immediately and issue a policy directive to Detroit police officers explaining that it is illegal to banish homeless individuals from Greektown or any other neighborhood of Detroit.
To watch a video of Andrew Sheehan and others discuss this practice, go to:http://www.aclumich.org/
To read the ACLU’s letter to DPD, go to: http://bit.ly/101PN2k
To read the ACLU’s DOJ complaint, go to: http://bit.ly/11lngG7
Latest posts by Kenneth D. Price (aka bloggerken) (see all)
- Subscribe to LowdCrowd - September 7, 2018
- Re-Righting History: Katie Couric Looks At Confederate Monuments - May 16, 2018
- Inside Zionism: Moving the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem - May 14, 2018
- Irish Slavery Myth: Fake History in the Aftermath of Charlottesville - August 21, 2017
- Will It Ever End? Charlottesville, Virginia and the Enemy Within - August 12, 2017